The contestants often would say that "we're ALL winners in the end,"
since the least amount they walk home with is $5000 (on top of what they
already won in their state and local pageants). Still, when you consider how
they're all put through the paces for the three weeks leading up to the
telecast as well as anywhere from a year to a lifetime's worth of
preparation that money doesn't seem like much of a "prize." It's hard
earned income!
They're providing ABC with three hours worth of free prime-time eye
candy, which to my mind smacks of exploitation. I don't know how much the
ABC/Disney corporation contributes to the non-profit Miss America
Organization (which doled out $35 million in scholarships alone last year),
but you'd think they'd want to make sure that the contestants on the telecast
"win" a lot more than a paltry 5 grand.
You also have to wonder what the contestants really expect to get out of
this in the long run, aside from the experience itself. Several previous
winners have gone on to high-profile careers (such as Lee Meriwether, Phyllis
George, and that notorious orange juice shilling homo-hater Anita Bryant*),
but most of them seem content to marry a politician or Texas oilman and fade
into comfortable obscurity.
The talent competition in particular has a very Victorian "finishing
school" feel to it, as if the ultimate goal of all of their efforts is to
land a good husband. During the preliminaries the reigning Miss America,
Heather French, pointed out her fiancee in the audience, as the spotlight
landed on this pudgy, balding, middle-aged doctor. Typical! Aah, but I'm
sure he's a nice guy, and her mother must be thrilled, so I should mind my
own business...
*Anita's anti-gay activities back in the '70s seem even more bizarre to
me now, after having seen first hand what a large and enthusiastic part of
The Pageant's following is made up of gay men.)